Where authors, writers, editors, publishers, producers, directors, and media professionals meet  
 
The Twelve Most Worthless Things

March
Society Lounge

 
 

Members Only SCRIBE! Media Machine - Your Personal Media Machine
All-FREE Quarterly Writer's Magazine - Always
We Can Help You on Your Road to Success
Our Professional Members' Hottest Works
We Promote Books Like Crazy at The Author's Place

Sometimes You've Gotta Go with Your Instincts

A few years ago, I ran across a story that I thought was worth a second look.  It was about a dolphin researcher down in the islands of the Caribbean somewhere.  Inexplicably, she was murdered, and no one ever discovered why.

Well, that got me to thinking about doing an In Cold Blood type of story, narrative nonfiction, an expose, and I set about trying to get the facts, which got me nowhere.  Apparently, St. Kitts or St. Barts or wherever the hell she was when she'd been murdered wasn't overly anxious for people dwelling on the story, for obvious reasons.


Unwilling to give up on a dynamite tale, I decided to turn the piece into historical fiction--just enough reality to lend credence to the story, and yet enough latitude to allow me to forge ahead without being bothered by all of those pesky little details we call "facts."

Naturally, I had high hopes for the story.  Naturally, no one was interested.  In fact, I hadn't had a single publisher request so much as a glance at the property in nearly three years...until last month.  Elated that someone finally found the story as intriguing as I did, I sent off the outline and three sample chapters pronto.

And then I got the response.

Thank you for thinking of Dutton for TO DANCE WITH DOLPHINS.  I enjoyed reading the sample chapters.  Ultimately, however, I decided against pursuing this project.  I’m afraid I didn’t find the story compelling enough.  It seemed too conventional to stand out among other adventure books. 

I’m sorry I don’t have better news for you.  I appreciate your giving me the chance to read this material, and I wish you success in finding an enthusiastic editor for it very soon.

Now, rejections are nothing new to me.  I've been in this business a long time.  The part that really irked me, though, was that I had always felt, deep down inside, that my outline was weak.  It told a story, of course, but I was never convinced that it was the best story I could possibly have worked around the incident.

Instead of listening to my instincts, I decided to send what I had out anyway in the hope that I was wrong and that someone, somewhere, would fall in love with it and make me an offer I couldn't refuse.

All of which is a convoluted, long, drawn-out way of saying this: If you don't feel it's the absolute best you can do, don't send it out.  Take some time to rewrite it, edit it, sharpen it, strengthen it.  Then, when you're convinced that you've nailed the beast, send it out.

The editor will understand.  In fact, most editors would be glad to wait a month or two or three or longer for a writer who's working on improving the finished product.

So the next time you get a request from an editor or a producer or anyone wanting to see some work you're not totally convinced is the best you can possibly crank out, uh-uh.  Don't do it.  Don't succumb.  Take the time to get all your ducks in a row.  After all, duck-hunting season comes 'round only once a year.  Don't get caught with a 12-gauge Mossberg in your hands and all of the shells in your pocket.

And, of course, always remember what my great-great-great grandmother on my mother's side never told me whenever advising me on matters just such as this:  Son...

Smoke if you got ‘em.

                     
                       D. J. Herda
                       President

 

A Special Invitation
To Non-Members
  • Find the only contacts you'll ever need to make it BIG as a freelance writer and check out the benefits of joining the American Society of Authors and Writers.  You'll receive a national Press Card, a certificate of membership, and a monthly subscription to SCRIBE! Media Magazine, filled with the kind of information that will help keep YOU ahead of the pack.  All for $5 a month or less.
     

  • Enroll a friend or family member today and we'll send a special Gift Membership Card by Priority Mail--the perfect gift for any occasion

Nominate Someone for Membership in AmSAW
( )


 

HOME - THE SWETKY AGENCY -
 

Google Custom Search

NOTE: All material on this site is copyright protected.  No portion of this material may be copied or reproduced, either electronically,  mechanically, or by any other means, for resale or distribution without the written consent of the author.  All copy has been dated and registered with the American Society of Authors and Writers.  Copyright 2008 by the American Society of Authors and Writers.