Where authors, writers, editors, publishers, producers, directors, and media professionals meet

December 2008
Commentary

Google Custom Search


If Truth Be Told

              by D. J. Herda

I came across an interesting article by Caroline Gammell the other day.  It talked about how men lie about the things they have read in order to impress their dates.  It went on to say that men are twice as likely as women to lie about what reading materials they have devoured to try to impress someone on a first date and that exaggerating the extent of a man's literary prowess is second only to false boasts about his previous conquests in bed.

The article based its conclusions on a poll that showed that 39 percent of all Brits--that's right, it was taken across the pond in Great Britain--are less than honest about what they have read and more likely to lie about their reading habits than they are about their age or job.

Now, I'm going to be honest with you.  I really am.  I was absolutely convinced that the article was a fake until I read the part about the study being done overseas.  I mean, the Brits?  Absolutely.  I have traveled extensively throughout England, and I can absolutely see British men taking great boastful pride in extolling their literary virtues to members of the fairer sex.  After all, Brits.  Great Britain.  The British Empire.  You know, Shakespeare, Yeats, and Rowling?

I had my doubts, however, that a similar study conducted here in the good ol' U. S. of A. would generate similar results.  I had doubts, but I wasn't sure, so I approached my good friend U. R. Whadyread and asked him to replicate the poll right here in America. He did.

And what did he discover?

Whadyread: I am discovered by a very interesting fact.  According to my research, more than 78 percent of all American men lie regularly about what they have read in order to impress their potential conquests, some of whom are actually women.

D. J.: Wow, 78 percent!  That's astounding!

Whadyread: Ya, it is.  At first I am thinking my research is skewed, you know?  Like when you ignore a bunch of hanging chads or neglect to count 300 votes that the local voter election judge forgot to bring in from the trunk of her car.

D. J.: And was it actually something so simple as that?

Whadyread: No!  My research turn out to be absolutely hundred-percent accurate, you know?  I prove this by going back to all men I poll and asking them specifically revealed questions, such as "What have you not yet read but have told a date or potential mate that you have read?"

D. J.: And you got some interesting responses?

Whadyread: Absolutely, yes.  One man reply that he tell his date that he read the King James Bible from cover-to-cover while he was missionary surfing in Hawaii.

D. J.: Cover to cover, wow.

Whachureed: Ya, and not only that.  But four times!

D. J.: And his date believed him?

Whadyread: Uhh, well, no, not exactly.  She asked him what he thought of Deuteronomy, and he reply that he knows it beats one-of-a-kind.

D. J.: Which goes to show that crime doesn't pay!

Whadyread: Huh?

D. J.: Never mind.  What other things did your poll discover that men are lying about having read?

Whadyread: Well, sixteen percent say they read Shakespeare's works, three percent say they read his work records, and one guy say he would have read his work records except that Shakespeare had quit the week before guy begins working there.

D. J.: Amazing.

Whadyread: Ya, and another 45 percent say they recently finished reading the back of the Viagra label.  One guy actually said to having read the label and was now frantically searching for information on how to reverse the process.

D. J.: Wow.  And he actually told that to his date?

Whachureed: Told to date?  Oh, yes.  They get marry each other next day!

D. J.: Oh, wow.

Whadyread: Ya, wow, but that's not half of it.  Of all things men quote as having read when they did not, more than 72 percent name Bridges of Madison County.

D. J.: Oh, my God.  And their dates actually believed them?

Whadyread: Well, all except one.  In a follow-up interview, he tell me: "Oh, honey, I didn't buy into that line for a minute.  I could tell he was just trying to get into my BVDs."

I thanked the good doctor and headed back to my study to think about everything I had learned.  All in all, I found the study quite revealing.  Of the top five reads used by the Brits to impress a date, here's the breakdown:

Top Reading Material Women Use To Impress Men

1) Current-affairs Websites
2) Shakespeare
3) Song lyrics
4) Cookbooks
5) Poetry
6) Nelson Mandela autobiography, Long Walk to Freedom

Top Reading Material Men Use to Impress Women

1) Nelson Mandela autobiography, Long Walk to Freedom
2) Shakespeare
3) Cookbooks
4) Poetry
5) Song lyrics
6) Current-affairs Websites

Is it just me, or is there a definite, albeit definitely less than distinctive, pattern emerging here?  And whatever happened to classic literature such as Black Beauty, Moby Dick, and Mad Magazine?  And, while we're asking questions here, why are men and women who are so obviously different in so many different ways so obviously single-minded when it comes to telling others what they have been reading?

For the answers to those and other questions, we may simply have to wait for next month's commentary, when we delve into that most pressing of all rhetorical questions: "Whatever did happen to Baby Jane?"

And I…am D. J. Herda.

#     #     #

D. J. Herda is President of the American Society of Authors and Writers (http://amsaw.org), an organization made up of authors, writers, editors, publishers, agents, directors, producers, and other media professionals who rely upon the printed word in the creation of quality literature and entertainment.  He is a member of the Author's Guild, a former member of the American Society of Journalists and Authors, and a former member of the National Press Club.  He has published more than 80 books and several hundred thousand articles, short stories, columns, interviews, plays, and scripts.
 


- BACK -